0

Truly Understanding

Posted by Simon Rhee on 10:58 PM
Directions: Think carefully about the issue presented in the following excerpt and the assignment below.
Author Betty Fridean wrote in the The Feminine Mystique. "The only way for a woman, as for a man, to know herself as a person, is by a creative work of her own." Others feel that self-understanding comes from within. Harvard psychologist Ellen J. Langer states, "In the perspective of every person lies a lens through which we may better understand ourselves." Carl Jung, founder of analytical psychology, is more specific about the role of others in our self-awareness when he states that "Everything that irritates us about others can lead us to an understanding of ourselves."

Assignment:
In your opinion what must we do to truly understand ourselves? In an essay, apply your position by discussing an example (or examples) from literature, the arts, science and technology, current events, or your own experience of observation.


According to Sigmund Freud, the human mind is divided into multiple layers. The outermost layer is the super-ego, which is the conscious, providing the emotion of guilt whenever you commit acts that go against the ideals and morals instilled at a young age. Then, working your way closer to the core and true desires, comes the ego, which is the reality that the mind perceives. Taking the primal instincts and desires that makes up the id, the ego rationalizes these drives and organizes thought so that it fits into reality. Passing the ego, one arrives at the id, the core, so to say, if you were to imagine the human mind as a big planet, with the crust being the super-ego (albeit a rather thick crust), the mantle being the ego. The id is the raw emotions and desires, the instant gratification. Here is the true nature of a human being, not defined by the rules and limitations of society.

It is argued that the id is in direct contrast to the super-ego, and when the conflict raises to an immense amount, psychiatric problems occur. However, just as the crust is the visible portion of Planet Earth, so is the super-ego, tricking the mind to think and deny the primitive desires of the id. Therefore, most people in modern society, living in comfort and not living on a day to day basis, resorts to the super-ego rather than the id, and often end up denying the true nature they hold inside themselves. Therefore, in order for a person to completely know himself, they must have their inner id take control, reacting based upon their instincts, rather than strictly from a rational standpoint. Just as the great Romantics of the 19th century criticized the Scientific Revolution for over-rationalizing things that must come from the heart, the id fights off the super-ego which criticizes the primitive thoughts of the id. However, the core is what drives the human being and is the true inner being, and thus, the question is: how do you bring out the inner id? The answer: a traumatic experience, one that forces a person to skip the rationalizing and jump straight to the basic instinct. Unfortunately, without a traumatic experience, the super-ego overpowers the id, and thus one may never truly come to understand themselves.

So why traumatic experience? Well, in all reality, not everyone needs a traumatic experience to truly get in touch with their id. Yet, it is one of the most sure ways to truly find how you will react. A saying that is often quoted to big talkers is "Act on your words." Many times, people convince themselves that they will react in one way, when in reality, they react in another way when the difficult situation arises. Case in point: Men. All men know that they will not cry. They constantly tell themselves that they will not cry. Even if they have their arm chopped off and then have a carrot shoved up the stump of an arm left, they will not cry. Unfortunately, modern society condemns men to cry in any situation, least of all publicly. However, grown men do tear up, whether it be when Bambi's mother dies, or when their only son says something that stabs the heart with a million pins. The id is the inner emotion, the thing that is TELLING the eyes to tear up, softening the heart, infusing depression, sorrow, and confusion into one ball. The super-ego, however, tells the body otherwise: Men do not cry. As a result, you have what some people call the quivering lip; aka the face spasm. So, to bypass the super-ego reaction, one must be placed in a situation where any rational thinking is impossible, when thought is not the major factor, the heart is.

These situations include the child pinned under a car incident. The mother can react in multiple ways. One extreme is for the mother to rush in and lift the car up to pull out her child. The other extreme is for the mother to just look at the car and realize there is no hope and walk away. Of course, their are reactions in between. But, a mother does not know how she will react until the situation presents itself. The mother who won't save her children is not necessarily the bad mother. How can you call a natural reaction bad. It is that the desire to save her children is overpowered by the danger of lifting the car up. There are other cases in which the mind must react without consulting reality or the conscious, such as the situation in the movie Felon. Do you attack the burglar who threatened the safety of your family or passively protect your family by placing yourself between the burglar and your loved ones? The dilemma is not just black and white, it is often in shades of gray. Knowing where you fall within the shades of gray is difficult, and thus many people do not truly understand themselves until they deal with a distressing incident.

-Says Simon

0 Comments

Post a Comment

Copyright © 2009 SIMON SAYS All rights reserved. Theme by Laptop Geek. | Bloggerized by FalconHive.