0
Ignorance is Bliss
Posted by Simon Rhee
on
8:09 PM
(This is not necessarily an SAT essay, but its homework I received at my SAT prep place. So basically the same thing)
The Maggots in Your Mushrooms
E.J. Levy - New York Times
Here is the link to the news article: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/opinion/13levy.html
Here are some of the interesting portions:
Assignment: We have all heard the saying, "Ignorance is bliss." Do you agree or disagree? You may use the above article as an example to prove your point.
To be quite honest, when I first received this article I was intrigued. But as I proceeded to read this, I was revolted, pretty much disgusted at the things that we eat daily. My sister is scared of any and all types of bugs, even ants (which she yells for me to kill as she stands a full 10 feet away pointing at it). If she realized that the food she eats on a day to day basis, the peanut butter in her sandwich, the juice she drinks, includes the very organisms she hates, whether or not she would vomit is an interesting SAT question in itself.
But the question is: Is ignorance bliss? and not: Is this article revolting? Before going into an analysis on my opinion, it should be noted that ignorance doesn't necessarily mean stupidity. There is a difference between choosing not to know something and not having the resources to know that information. Ignorance is the former, while the latter is stupidity. To provide a concrete example, ignorance is when you hear a car approaching you and you choose to ignore it. Stupidity is when you have no idea the car is coming at you because you're too preoccupied with your game of Touch Touch on your iPhone. So, in this example, its clear ignorance is not bliss: if you knew the car was approaching, you could evade danger and live to the next day. By ignoring it, you are greeting Death with open arms. But is ignorance always a negative thing? Not necessarily.
When ignorance threatens the safety of oneself, it is certainly detrimental. The volcanic explosion of Pompeii comes to mind. Thousands of citizens were covered in molten lava and ash because the scientists and ruler of that region chose to ignore the rumblings and volcanic ash spewing from the volcano of Pompeii. Go back to my example of the impeding car. But when information does not necessarily affect ones safety and will cause one to only be revolted, is ignorance the better choice? The answer here is not so clear cut. In my opinion, ignorance may be the better choice for some, and as the term goes, ignorance may be bliss.
My reasoning is this: since enlightenment doesn't provide any difference in safety, the only outcome from the new information will be more stressed. Because I feel disgusted after reading the new article doesn't mean anything will change, nor will it be changing in the near future. Instead, I'll be forced to eat ketchup but rather than enjoying good ole' Heinz, I will be reminded that I am ingesting spider eggs and rat feces. Not necessarily a pleasant thought. Of course the opponents of ignorance will quote that people need to be enlightened and all information is healthy and important. Many times, people truly do need to face reality, and when ignorance clashes with a healthy lifestyle, that is also detrimental.
So in all conclusion, I find that ignorance, in some cases, is bliss. However, its important to take that statement with a grain of salt. Just as ignoring a rapidly approaching car won't make it disappear, it's important to maintain a strong connection with reality. Or else, it could lead to something bad (or in the case of global warming, the destruction of the planet).
-Says Simon
The Maggots in Your Mushrooms
E.J. Levy - New York Times
Here is the link to the news article: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/13/opinion/13levy.html
Here are some of the interesting portions:
"THE Georgia peanut company at the center of one of our nation’s worst food-contamination scares has officially reached a revolting new low: a recent inspection by the Food and Drug Administration discovered that the salmonella-tainted plant was also home to mold and roaches."
"In its (falsely) reassuringly subtitled booklet “The Food Defect Action Levels: Levels of Natural or Unavoidable Defects in Foods That Present No Health Hazards for Humans,” the F.D.A.’s Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition establishes acceptable levels of such “defects” for a range of foods products, from allspice to peanut butter.
Among the booklet’s list of allowable defects are “insect filth,” “rodent filth” (both hair and excreta pellets), “mold,” “insects,” “mammalian excreta,” “rot,” “insects and larvae” (which is to say, maggots), “insects and mites,” “insects and insect eggs,” “drosophila fly,” “sand and grit,” “parasites,” “mildew” and “foreign matter” (which includes “objectionable” items like “sticks, stones, burlap bagging, cigarette butts, etc.”)."
"Peanut butter — that culinary cause célèbre — may contain approximately 145 bug parts for an 18-ounce jar; or five or more rodent hairs for that same jar; or more than 125 milligrams of grit."
Assignment: We have all heard the saying, "Ignorance is bliss." Do you agree or disagree? You may use the above article as an example to prove your point.
To be quite honest, when I first received this article I was intrigued. But as I proceeded to read this, I was revolted, pretty much disgusted at the things that we eat daily. My sister is scared of any and all types of bugs, even ants (which she yells for me to kill as she stands a full 10 feet away pointing at it). If she realized that the food she eats on a day to day basis, the peanut butter in her sandwich, the juice she drinks, includes the very organisms she hates, whether or not she would vomit is an interesting SAT question in itself.
But the question is: Is ignorance bliss? and not: Is this article revolting? Before going into an analysis on my opinion, it should be noted that ignorance doesn't necessarily mean stupidity. There is a difference between choosing not to know something and not having the resources to know that information. Ignorance is the former, while the latter is stupidity. To provide a concrete example, ignorance is when you hear a car approaching you and you choose to ignore it. Stupidity is when you have no idea the car is coming at you because you're too preoccupied with your game of Touch Touch on your iPhone. So, in this example, its clear ignorance is not bliss: if you knew the car was approaching, you could evade danger and live to the next day. By ignoring it, you are greeting Death with open arms. But is ignorance always a negative thing? Not necessarily.
When ignorance threatens the safety of oneself, it is certainly detrimental. The volcanic explosion of Pompeii comes to mind. Thousands of citizens were covered in molten lava and ash because the scientists and ruler of that region chose to ignore the rumblings and volcanic ash spewing from the volcano of Pompeii. Go back to my example of the impeding car. But when information does not necessarily affect ones safety and will cause one to only be revolted, is ignorance the better choice? The answer here is not so clear cut. In my opinion, ignorance may be the better choice for some, and as the term goes, ignorance may be bliss.
My reasoning is this: since enlightenment doesn't provide any difference in safety, the only outcome from the new information will be more stressed. Because I feel disgusted after reading the new article doesn't mean anything will change, nor will it be changing in the near future. Instead, I'll be forced to eat ketchup but rather than enjoying good ole' Heinz, I will be reminded that I am ingesting spider eggs and rat feces. Not necessarily a pleasant thought. Of course the opponents of ignorance will quote that people need to be enlightened and all information is healthy and important. Many times, people truly do need to face reality, and when ignorance clashes with a healthy lifestyle, that is also detrimental.
So in all conclusion, I find that ignorance, in some cases, is bliss. However, its important to take that statement with a grain of salt. Just as ignoring a rapidly approaching car won't make it disappear, it's important to maintain a strong connection with reality. Or else, it could lead to something bad (or in the case of global warming, the destruction of the planet).
-Says Simon

Post a Comment